Tom Lemanski's

Your Bridge to Discovery

Leadership Breakthroughs icon

The Only Thing Worse Than an Incompetent Subordinate

Hard Worker

For a manager, what’s the one thing worse than an incompetent subordinate? The answer to this old corporate axiom and riddle surprised and amused me so much that it inspired this briefing. The answer…

The only thing worse than an incompetent subordinate is a hard working, incompetent subordinate.

Hard Worker

Why is this so True?

Here are two more commonly held axioms to help explain it.

The First Rule of Holes: When you’re in one, stop digging.

The hard working incompetent doesn’t know when to stop digging. He/she gets deeper and deeper into trouble and the damage takes longer for you to un-do if it can be repaired at all.

The Puritan Ethic: Work hard and become successful.

All too often our admiration for raw effort blinds us to the fact that little is being achieved. In organizations where measurable accountability wanes, one of the few criteria we have for evaluating performance is effort. Bob works so hard, how can we criticize him? The Puritan Ethic can lead us to confuse activity with achievement.

What about Your Subordinates?

Do you have any hard working incompetents that are hindering your potential for achievement?

  • Is anyone taking too long to do their otherwise routine tasks or putting in too many hours after everyone else has gone home?
  • Is the situation being fostered by a lack of accountability?
  • Are your people working hard or working smart?

A 3 Step Remedy

  1. Establish Measurable SMART Goals for every position and monitor and discuss their progress.
  2. If your people cannot display the competency to achieve, they are likely in the wrong job. As long as you foster or ignore this, who is really being served?
  3. Establish competency models for your positions and assess new candidates for the proper fit.

Related Articles

What about When The Subordinate is More Proficient than the Boss?

There is a time and place to embrace or even celebrate your ignorance.

2 Responses

  1. I had a devious, deceitful subordinate. I was out of town on business. While gone, it went to the corporate president and said my top client wanted to work with him, not me. When I called in for messages, I was transferred to the president and told of the conversation. I immediately called the client, who was surprised by the request.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *